BHRIGUNATH SINGH Vs. STATE OF JHARKHAND

JUDGEMENT

(1.) THE present petition has been preferred against an order passed by respondent no. 4 dated 27th August, 2002 at Annexure 17 to the memo of the present petition, whereby the respondents have denied granting B.A. trained scale to the petitioner.

(2.) I have heard counsel for the petitioner, who has submitted that initially the writ petition bearing C. W.J.C. No. 2178 of 1990 (R) was preferred by the petitioner for getting B.A. trained scale whereby it has been stated that all other juniors of the petitioner were given B.A. trained scale and, therefore, this Court had directed respondent no. 5 to decide the case of the present petitioner for getting B.A. trained scale. Thereafter, no decision was taken by the concerned respondent authorities and, therefore, another writ petition bearing C.W.J.C. No. 4299 of 1996 (R) was preferred by the petitioner and this Court had taken note of the lethargic approach of the concerned officer and pointed out that respondents have not taken care to read the earlier order. With these observations for the respondent officers, once again direction was given to respondent no. 5 to pass an order upon claim of the petitioner for getting B.A. trained scale.

(3.) I have heard counsel for respondent nos. 1 to 5, who has submitted that looking to the order at Annexure 17 to the memo of the present petition dated 27th August, 2002, if the services rendered by the petitioner are not satisfactory, then petitioner is not entitled for B.A. trained scale, which has been communicated by respondent no. 4 and, therefore, petitioner is not given B.A. trained scale and, therefore, the present petition deserves to be dismissed.