(1.) THESE appeals arise out of common judgment dated 20.3.2005 passed in Reference Cases Nos. 2 of 2001, 3 of 2001 and 4 of 2001 by Tribunal Judge, C.B.A. Act, Rajmahal Project Area, Lalmatia at Godda. Counsel appearing for the appellant (second party) submitted that the learned Tribunal did not decide whether the marriage between the Pradhan Kisku and Bitiya Baskey was in 'Gharjamai form or not. She further submitted that the Pradhan Kisku deserted Bitiya Baskey and therefore, the land reverted back to the second party. After considering the materials on record in detail, the court below recorded the following findings: -