(1.) Heard learned counsel for the parties.
(2.) By the impugned Award dated 09.05.2011 [Annexure -5] passed by Central Government Industrial Tribunal No. 1, Dhanbad in Reference No. 51 of 2000, the following reference "Whether the action of M/s. BCCL, Kusunda Area management in not absorbing the female 35 workers or their nominated alternate males is in violation of the bi -partite agreement arrived at between the management and the Union If so, to what relief the concerned workmen are entitled - has been answered in the following terms:
(3.) The substratum of the case is that workmen herein raised their grievance under an Agreement dated 09.12.1980 between Management and Union, para -2 whereof is also quoted in the impugned Award and is extracted as under: -