GOVIND MAHTO Vs. STATE OF JHARKHAND

JUDGEMENT

(1.) THIS application under Sec. 482 of the Code of Criminal Procedure (hereinafter to be referred as 'Code ') has been filed for quashing the order dated 9.11.2002 whereby cognizance has been taken.

(2.) PROSECUTION case in brief is that Shri Awadh Kishore Thakur, supply inspector, Chandankiyari lodged an FIR with Chas PS on 31.8.2002 being Chas PS Case No. 116 of 2002 alleging therein that he got a confidential information that dealers of public distribution system of Chandankiyari have taken wheat of red cards to Chas Bazar area for the purpose of black marketing and accordingly the informant informed the officer -in -charge Chas PS and he along with District Supply Officer. Chandankiyari left for Chas Bazar in a motorcycle and they reached Jodhadih More at 2.30 pm where the officer -in -charge, Chas PS was present along with officers of the department and truck bearing registration No. BR -20G -866 and BR -20F -8674 were standing towards Jodhadih More and during the course of inspection/search, he found in truck No. BR - 20G -866 120 bags of wheat weighing 50 kg. each and in truck No. BR -20F -8674 he found 150 bags of wheat weighing 50 kg. each and on inquiry from the two dealers, namely. Govind Mahto and Dilip Sharma, he came to know that they were carrying the red card holders wheat and on being asked they produced the receipt of purchase from the Bihar State Food and Civil Supply Corporation, sold by them to dealers. He came to know that 169 bags of what sold to Govind Mahto, the total weight 86.10 quintal for selling in his in Jodhadih panchayat while in truck No. BR -20G -866 only 120 bags of wheat weighing 60 quintal was found and nothing was told to them about the shortage and, therefore, it was believed that the wheat which fell short of the required quantity was sold in black market. 160 bags of wheat was sold to Dilip Sharma but there were 159 bags of wheat, he could not explain the shortage of wheat by one bag. Further case of the prosecution is that trucks in question when going straight to Jodhadih panchayat via Manpur preferred rout to Chandankiyari to Chas for the purpose of black marketing and they were caught at the Jodhadih More. The driver of truck No. BR -20G -866 disclosed that he was taking wheat from Chandankiyari to Chas but he could not say where he was going to unload the wheat at Chas as wheat owner was coming from behind. The FIR further disclosed that both the dealers were taking wheat from Chandankiyari to Chas Bazar for black marketing.

(3.) ON the other hand, learned State counsel failed to state as to what provisions of Essential Commodities Act have been violated.