MOHAMMED ARSHAD Vs. STATE OF RAJASTHAN

JUDGEMENT

(1.) BY an order dated 29.08.1980, the Governor of Rajasthan granted sanction for creation of two divisions and nine sub-divisions of Public Health Engineering Department with necessary supporting staff including the posts of Foreman Grade-I, Senior Driller, Driller, Compressor cum Machine Operator, Assistant Driller, Mechanic Grade-I, Electrician Grade-I, Driver, Lower Division Clerk cum Time Keeper, Mechanic Grade-II, Welder, Fitter-II, Mason, Blacksmith, Helper and Helper cum Cleaner. As a consequent to the process of selection conducted to fill up the posts aforesaid appointments were accorded to the petitioners as Compressor Driver vide order dated 03.09.1981 passed by the Executive Engineer, Drilling and Handpump Division, Public Health Engineering Department, Jodhpur. It is relevant to mention here that no post in the name of Compressor Driver was sanctioned under the order dated 29.08.1980, though a post of Compressor cum Machine Operator was shown therein.

(2.) THE executive Engineer Drilling and Handpump, Public Health Engineering Department, Jodhpur vide communication dated 27.07.1983 made a recommendation for regularization of the petitioners' services as Compressor cum Machine Operator in view of the fact that no bar was there for making appointments on technical posts. Subsequent thereto under an order dated 18.12.1991, the Government of Rajasthan changed nomenclature of the post of Compressor cum Machine Operator as Boring operator. An order dated 14.02.1996 then was passed by the Additional Chief Engineer, Public Health Engineering Department, Drilling Region, Jaipur absorbing the petitioners in regular cadre with effect from 01.04.1985 with the designation of Compressor Driver, however, vide the corrigendum dated 08.07.2002, they came to be regularized in service from the date of their initial appointment, i.e. 03.09.1981. Suffice to note that under an order dated 14.02.1996, it was made clear that on being taken on regular cadre, the services and other service conditions of the petitioners shall be governed under the Rajasthan Engineering Subordinate (Public Health Branch) Rules, 1967 (for short, 'the Rules of 1967').

(3.) THE order impugned dated 17.08.2010 then was passed by the Deputy Secretary (Second) to the Government of Rajasthan, Department of Public Health and Engineering directing the Chief Engineer (Administration), Department of Public Health and Engineering to post the petitioners as Compressor Drivers instead of Boring Operators. A direction was also given to recover from the petitioner's the amount said to be paid in excess by treating them Boring Operator. Aggrieved by the order dated 17.08.2010, this petition for writ is preferred.