ANUBHA PRABHUNE Vs. STATE OF RAJASTHAN

JUDGEMENT

(1.) THE petitioner has challenged the orders dated 3-2-2012 and amended order dated 14-3-2012 passed by the Additional Collector (Stamps) Jaipur on the ground that the orders have been passed without giving an opportunity of hearing to her.

(2.) THE facts of the case are that the petitioner as a vendee entered into an oral agreement to purchase on or about 25-1-2003 with Manak Raj Jain, the Chief Trustee of Raj Welfare Trust 6/4 Taron ki Koot, Durgapura Jaipur, the vendor who agreed to sell the property i.e. 0.91 hectare land in village Durgapura Tehsil Sanganer, District Jaipur for a sum of Rs.1.5 crore. Later in the year 2009 due to general rise in the price of land, under a memorandum dated 21-8-2009 price of the land was settled as Rs.4.5 crore, out of which the petitioner paid Rs.22,000/- as advance, and the balance amount was to be paid by her to the vendor at the time of registration of sale-deed. A dispute thereafter arose between the vendor and vendee owing to the vendor's disinclination to honour the agreement to sell and execute a sale deed in favour of the petitioner. Consequently the petitioner filed a suit No.105/2009, Smt. Anubha Prabhune Vs. Rajasthan Welfare Trust in the court of Additional District Judge No.9, Jaipur Metropolitan City, Jaipur for specific performance of the agreement to sell dated 21-8-2009.

(3.) IT appears that on the reference by the trial court to the Additional Collector (Stamps) Jaipur, the matter was registered on 3-2-2012 by the Additional Collector (Stamps) Jaipur as case No.812/2011 and he without hearing the petitioner proceeded to assess the stamp duty on the agreement to sell dated 21-8-2009, at Rs.13,49,900/-, and taking into consideration the fact that stamp duty was not paid at the time of the execution indicative of an intent to evade payment of stamp duty due, the Additional Collector (Stamps) Jaipur levied a penalty ten times of the stamp duty as Rs.1,34,99,000/- vide impugned order dated 3-2-2012. Subsequently, the learned Additional Collector (Stamps) Jaipur without notice to the petitioner issued an amended order dated 14-3-2012 and included the amount of surcharge also as Rs.1,34,900/-, thus total amount was assessed as Rs.1,49,83,890/-.