ALKA Vs. STATE AND ORS.

JUDGEMENT

(1.) ALL the Petitioners had participated in process of selection initiated by Rajasthan Public Service Commission for the post of Lecturer (School Education) pursuant to advertisement No. 1/2008 -09/dt. 10/05/2008 and after having qualified in screening test, were called for interview but could not be finally selected, have approached by way of instant petitions.

(2.) MAIN grievance for filing of instant petitions is that under Scheme of Rules, 1970, State Government made amendments in existing Rr. 16, 18 & 19 by which Rr. 18A, 18B & 19A were added in Rules of 1970 vide notification dt. 01/04/1998 and in terms of R. 19A, such candidates having obtained minimum qualifying marks in written examination as may be fixed by the PSC in their discretion are to be summoned for interview and taking assistance (School Lecturer) thereof, main thrust of Petitioners is that written examination held by the PSC is a part of selection process held pursuant to advertisement impugned herein and the marks obtained therein by individual applicant are to be added to the marks obtained by them in process of interview to be considered for preparation of final select list but R. 19A of Rules, 1970 being added vide amendment notification dt. 01/04/1998 has not been looked into and taken note of by the PSC while publication of final select/merit list; and their action being in contravention of Scheme of Rules, 1970, select list prepared by PSC, itself, deserves to be set aside, and the PSC may be commanded to prepare fresh select/merit list of all the applicants participated in process of selection impugned herein after taking note of their marks obtained in written examination held in the form of screening test & interview - in absence whereof, action of Respondent -PSC is wholly arbitrary being in violation of Article 14 of the Constitution of India and also of R. 19A of Rules, 1970.

(3.) FU /kkZfjr vfuok;Z ;ksX;rk,a U;wure gS vkSj bu ;ksX;rkvksa ds gksus ls gh vH;kFkhZ lk{kkRdkj gsrq cqyk;s tkus ds gdnkj ugha gks tkrs gS A tc fdlh foKkiu ds vk/kkj ij izkIr vkosnu i=ksa dh la[;k vf/kd gksxh vkSj vk;ksx ds fy, bu lHkh vH;kfFkZ;ksa dk lk{kkRdkj djuk lqfo/kktud ;k laHko ugha gksxk] rks vk;ksx foKkiu esa fu/kkZfjr U;wure ;ksX;rkvksa vkSj vuqHko ds vk/kkj ij vFkok laoh{kk ijh{kk }kjk lk{kkRdkj gsrq vH;kfFkZ;ksa dh la[k;k ;Fkksfpr lhek rd de dj ldrk gS A