HIND CONSTRUCTIONS LTD Vs. CESS DEPUTY COLLECTOR

JUDGEMENT

(1.) The petitioners are two limited companies, namely, Hind Constructions Limited and Patel Engineering Company Limited, incorporated, under the Indian Companies Act, and jointly executing the work of construction of Konar Dam No. 1 in the district of Hazaribagh. The Damo-dar Valley Corporation (hereinafter called "the Corporation") is a statutory body incorporated under Central Act 14 of 1948. For the purpose of construction of Konar Dam No. 1, the Government of Bihar acquired lands after issuing declarations under Section 6 of Act 1 Of 1394 and Section 3, Clause 1, of Act 18 of 1885. According to the form of declaration title was acquired not only to the surface right but also such part of the mines and minerals like coal, iron-stone, slate etc. which it might be necessary to dig, or carry away, or use in the construction of the Dam. The condition is expressed in negative form in the declaration (Annexure A) :

(2.) In these circumstances, the petitioners have moved the High Court for grant of a writ in the nature of certiorari under Article 226 of the Constitution for , the purpose of calling up and quashing the proceedings started by the Cess Deputy Collector of Hazaribagh under Section 72 of the Cess Act (Bengal Act 9 of 1880). The contention of the petitioners is that they are not owners or managers or occupiers of any mine or quarry within the meaning of Section 72 of the Cess Act, and the Cess Deputy Collector had no jurisdiction to start a proceeding against the petitioners requiring them to submit a return of the net annual profits of the quarry. The case of the petitioners is that they were mere contractors and the notice issued under Section 72 of the Cess Act was illegal and beyond the jurisdiction of the Cess Deputy Collector.

(3.) Cause has been shown in this case by the learned Government Advocate on behalf of respondents 1 to 3 including the State of Eihar and Mr. Baldeva Sahay on behalf of respondent 4, the Damodar Valley Corporation.