STATE ELECTRICITY BOARD Vs. COMMISSIONER APPEALS

JUDGEMENT

(1.) BRIEFLY stated, the facts of this case are that an old mechanical meter installed in the factory premises of respondent No. 3, namely, vijay Kumar, was ordered to be replaced with new electronic meter as a routine matter on 8-2-2001 vide M. C. O. No. 6/054114 issued on 8-1 -2001. The old mechanical meter was got checked and as per the report of the M. E. Laboratory the meter was found running slow by 16. 82 per cent. A demand of Rs. 2,23,550/-was raised against respondent No. 3 by the petitioner-Punjab State electricity Board (hereinafter referred to as the petitioner Board) vide memo. No. 1161 dated 27-2-2001 on account of the loss caused to the petitioner-Board due to slow running of the meter.

(2.) RESPONDENT No. 3 Vijay Kumar challenged the said demand notice by way of an appeal before the Commissioner (Appeals), patiala Division, Patiala, contending therein that the illegal demand of Rs. 2,23,550/- has been raised against him without disclosing the reason of any theft or any rule under which penalty had been imposed. He further contended that there was no fault on his part. The old meter was replaced by the petitioner Board from the premises as a routine matter and no theft /pilferage was detected till the replacement of the new meter as is evident from the report of M. C. O. dated 8-1-2001. Possiblity with regard to the old meter being slow with the passage of time due to wear and tear in the meter would not amount to any theft. The meter was provided by the Punjab State Electricity Board and, therefore, for its slow running, respondent no. 3 cannot be held liable.

(3.) THE Commissioner (Appeals) vide his order dated 4-10-2007 (Annexure P-7) while agreeing with the contention raised by the consumer observes that it is the duty of the petitioner-Board to check the serviceability of the meter and not of the consumer. For any such defect in the meter, which cannot be attributed to any act or omission on the part of the consumer, the consumer cannot be penalized.