(1.) THIS adjudicative pursuit beholds a triangular orientation of competing assertions centering around the centuries old religious institution adorned by the globally reverred deity, Shri Shri Maa Kamakhya nestled in the verdant Nilachal Hills overseeing the mighty river Brahmaputra from its southern bank. The aforementioned appeals mount a challenge to the judgment and order dated 6/8/2004 rendered in WP(C) No. 5385/2000 along with WP(C) Nos. 6184/2000 and 2955/2002. The deity as well has been made to figure in the legal wrangle encompassed in WP(C) 935/2005 in a bid to nullify the provisions of the Assam State Acquisition of Lands Belonging to Religious or Charitable Institutions of Public Nature Act, 1959 (for short, hereinafter referred to as 'the Act') with its amendment in the year 1987 integrating Section 25A thereto. The constitutional validity of this enactment as a whole has been impeached.
(2.) WHEREAS the appellant in W.A. No. 311/2004 was the writ petitioner in WP(C) No. 5385/2000 representing himself to be an administrator of the Kamakhya Debutter (hereinafter also referred to as "the Kamakhya Debutter Board/ Board"), one Sri Kamal Chandra Sarma [petitioner No.1 in WP(C) 6184/2000] designating himself to be Chairman of the Board has lifted the cudgel against the aforementioned decision in W.A. No. 312/2004. In view of their interpositions, the petitioners(s)/ appellant(s) have been referred to hereinafter in the alternative.
(3.) FROM time immemorial their existed a Peetha or jyonimudra (sacred sign/ emblem) of Goddess Shri Durga venerably known as Shri Kamakhya in the Nilachal Hills situated on the south bank of river Brahmaputra in the State of Assam. With this shrine as the principal deity, several other subsidiary peethas or shrines surfaced around it being located all over the aforenamed hill. The discovery of these peethas or shrines had been gradual with time. Mythology traces construction of the temples with walls and stone stairs uphill to the engineering feats of King Narakasura, thus, making the location known and accessible. After the vandalic invasion of the Kamakhya Hill by Kalapahar of Bengal, as the history testifies, the Koch Dynasty during its prime held its sway over the whole of Kamrup. It was King Naranarayana who then rebuilt the Kamakhya Temple and introduced a regular scheme of worship, thus, streamlining the then prevailing disorderly state of affairs. With the emergence of the Ahom regime, five upper districts in the Brahmaputra Valley including Kamrup with the Nilachal Hills came under its rule. Since then till the advent of British in Assam in 1826, the Ahom Kings controlled and supervised all the affairs of the Kamakya Institution which had developed into a Tirtha-a supreme site of divine abode and acknowledged as a Government institution. It constituted a public religious endowment with all properties appertaining to it to be held in trust. Teeming masses principally professing Hindu religion thronged the site for divine audience and making devotional offerings in the shape of 'Pranamees'(fee), 'Naibedya', 'Bhogh'(cooked rice), fruits, sweets, clothes, ornaments, utensils etc.