JAGANNATH ENTERPRISE Vs. KOLKATA MUNICIPAL CORPORATION

JUDGEMENT

(1.) Item nos.10 to 13 involved similar questions of facts and law and by consent of parties I have taken them up together consolidated and heard them analogously. Item nos.12 and 13 did not disclose any purchase order. Item nos. 10 and 11 disclosed purchase order.

(2.) Documents have been discovered by the respondent Kolkata Municipal Corporation by an affidavit affirmed by Mr. Manas Som, Superintendent, Central Medical Stores of the Kolkata Municipal Corporation affirmed on the 9th day of September, 2019, which is taken on record and a copy has been served on Mr. Bose's advocate on record. The factual basis of Mr. Bose's submission have been admitted by the said deponent as appeared from paragraph 6 of the said affidavit, which is as follows ;

(3.) In my order dated July 25, 2019 after recording the entire ambit of the dispute I had categorically asked the following to be produced ; "Accordingly, the respondents are given liberty to produce the original records of the case including the price for procurement as prescribed by the Government and documents to show that these were accepted by the respondent no.1 before June 3, 2015, if at all available and how these were communicated to the petitioner before entering into the contract and also what steps have been taken against the then Superintendent, Central Medical Stores, Kolkata Municipal Corporation as alleged by the respondents in their earlier opposition."