VEDIC TRACOM PRIVATE LIMITED Vs. DHANANJOY JASRAPURIA

JUDGEMENT

(1.) THE respondents have no defence on merits to the present request under Section 11 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996. However, as is fashionable for dexterous litigants without any substantial defence, the only attempt is to delay the matter by referring to points which are of no concern to the respondents.

(2.) AT the initial stage of the present proceedings, it was submitted on behalf of the respondents that the document containing the arbitration clause was an unregistered agreement pertaining to an immovable property and, as such, the Court could not take cognizance thereof without due stamp duty in respect thereof being tendered. The original agreement was produced by the petitioner and it was directed to be carried to the appropriate official for assessment of stamp duty. It is not in dispute that stamp duty has been paid, but the respondents seek to make an issue as to the appropriateness of the stamp duty or the adequacy thereof. Such aspect of the matter is between the State and the person who presented the document and is of no concern of the respondents. As to the execution of the agreement for sale of the immovable property on March 26, 2011, the respondents are not in a position to deny the same. Indeed, it is the respondents' assertion that such agreement for sale had been terminated on June 13, 2011. The petitioner invoked the arbitration clause contained in the agreement for sale of March 26, 2011 by a letter of November 30, 2011. In response, the respondents asserted by their letter of December 5, 2011 that since the agreement had been terminated on June 13, 2011, there was no scope for invocation of the arbitration clause contained therein.

(3.) THE disputes between the parties are, inter alia, as to whether the agreement has been terminated or whether it could have been terminated or whether the petitioner had notice of such termination or accepted the same. These are matters which can be conveniently carried to an arbitration reference in accordance with the arbitration clause contained in the agreement of March 26, 2011.