(1.) FACTS
(2.) Vide judgment and order dated April 9, 2009 the Tribunal dismissed his application by observing that there was nothing wrong in acceptance of the gradation list published by the State in 2001. Hence, this petition before us. CONTENTIONS BEFORE US
(3.) Per contra, Mr. Apurbalal Basu, learned senior counsel appearing for Moni Sankar contended as follows :-