KALYAN KR CHATTERJEE Vs. STATE OF WEST BENGAL

JUDGEMENT

(1.) IN this revisional application the only short point that has been raised on behalf of the applicant is whether renewal of the eligibility certificate for the period July 1982 to June 1983 was rightly rejected by the Assistant Commissioner and whether the order of the Additional Commissioner confirming that order substantially is sustainable.

(2.) ADMITTED facts are : the applicant is a small-scale industrial unit and was granted eligibility certificate for the period January 24, 1981 to June 30, 1981. Thereafter the eligibility certificate was renewed for the year ended June 30, 1982. The applicant again applied for renewal on March 24, 1983 for another year ended June 30, 1983. This prayer for renewal for the period ending June, 1983 was rejected by the Assistant Commissioner by his order dated November 9, 1984. The applicant thereupon moved a revisional application before the Additional Commissioner who passed order dated May 22, 1989, who also rejected the prayer for renewal, but on somewhat different considerations. Thereupon the applicant has preferred the present application.

(3.) THE learned Additional Commissioner in disposing of the revisional application rightly observed that the first two grounds were minor in nature and not worthy of consideration. But he rejected the prayer on the following observations :