BADRI PRASAD Vs. STATE

JUDGEMENT

(1.) THIS is an application under Section 561a, Criminal P. C. for expunging certain remarks contained in the judgment of the City Magistrate of Lucknow. A proceeding was going on against the applicants under Sections 107/117, Criminal P. C. On 15th May 1953 the learned city Magistrate passed the following order :

(2.) IT appears from a perusal of this order that an apprehension at one time existed of a breach of the peace and proceedings were, therefore, started under Sections 107/117. These proceedings continued for some time and written statements were filed on behalf of the accused persons. Thereafter a report was made by the police that there was no longer any apprehension of a breach of the peace. The learned City Magistrate then passed the order in question.

(3.) IT appears from a perusal of the order that without going into the matter at all the learned magistrate was inclined to the view that at one time there had in fact been an occasion for a proper report under Sections 107 and 117, Criminal P. C. He had no justification whatsoever for arriving at any such conclusion without allowing an opportunity to the applicants to show that at no time was there any apprehension of a breach of the peace from them. When he was finally withdrawing the notice, he had no business to issue any warning. He had no reason to anticipate that the accused would give legitimate occasion for a report against them.