B SUBBULAKSHMI Vs. MANAGING DIRECTOR

JUDGEMENT

(1.) THIS writ petition has been filed praying for a Writ of Mandamus to direct the respondents 1 and 2 to accept the application for providing water supply and sewerage service connections and provide water supply and sewerage connections to petitioners' building situated at T.S.No.6549, Block No.141, Old Survey No.121/1 of T.Nagar Village at Chevaliar Sivaji Ganesan Salai, T.Nagar, Chennai-17, within the Corporation Zone VIII, on the basis of the Inspection Report filed by the third respondent in respect of the petitioners' premises in W.P.No.23895 of 2009.

(2.) BASED on the direction issued by this Court, the Chennai Metropolitan Development Authority has filed a report, dated 27.1.2010, which reads as follows: Description Dimension as per approved plan Dimension as on site Extent of Deviation/ViolationsTolerance limit as per Completion Certificate norms Whether satisfies Completion Certificate norms Set Back Front Set Back at Stilt Floor level North West6.16 m6.00 mLess by 0.16mTolerance limit 0.30 mYes Front Set Back at Stilt Floor level South West5.85m5.80mLess by 0.05 m Tolerance limit 0.30 m Yes From First Floor to 4th floor North West South West 5.21m 5.85 m 5.20 m 5.80 m Less by 0.01 m Less by 0.05m Tolerance limit 0.30 m Tolerance limit 0.30m -- Yes Rear Set Back At Stilt Floor level North East 7.11m 7.07m Less by 0.04m Tolerance limit 0.30 m Yes At Stilt Floor level South East 6.23m 6.21mLess by 0.02mTolerance limit 0.30 mYes From First floor level to 4th floors At North East 7.11m 7.07m Less by 0.04m Tolerance limit 0.30m Yes South East 6.23m6.21m Less by 0.02mTolerance limit 0.30mYes Side Set Back (South) North East 6.83m 7.00 m Excess by 0.17 m --- Yes North West 8.06m7.76mLess by 0.30m Tolerance limit 0.30 mYes From First floor level to 4th Floor level North East 6.83m 7.00 m Excess by 0.17 m --- Yes North West 8.06 m7.76mLess by 0.30mTolerance limit 0.30 mYes Side Set Back (South at Stilt Floor level South East South West 6.02 m 7.07m 6.11m 7.00 m Excess by 0.09m Excess by 0.07m --- -- Yes Yes From First Floor to 4th Floor South East South West 6.02 m 7.07m 6.11m 7.00 m Excess by 0.09m Excess by 0.07m --- -- Yes Yes Length of building Dimension at Stilt Floor 22.55m 22.55m -- -- Yes From first floor to 4th Floor 22.55m 22.55m --- --- Yes Width of building at north at Stilt Floor level 17.64m 17.90mExcess by 0.16mTolerance limit 0.30mYes From First floor to 4th floor 17.64m 17.90mExcess by 0.16mTolerance limit 0.30m Yes Width of building at South at Stilt Floor level (South side) 17.64m 17.90mExcess by 0.16mTolerance limit 0.30m Yes Height Stilt Floor Beam Bottom Bottom of Sky 2.20m 2.84 m 2.20m 2.50m --- --- --- --- --- --- Floor Space Index1.44 1.52 Excess by 0.02 i.e. 20.04 m2Tolerance limit 0.03 or 50 sq.mYes Parking12 Nos.12 Nos.--------Yes