LAWS(CE)-2010-3-120

TEJWANT SINGH Vs. CC

Decided On March 15, 2010
TEJWANT SINGH Appellant
V/S
Cc Respondents

JUDGEMENT

(1.) THESE three batches of appeals involving 17 appeals arose out of 3 (three) orders of adjudications made issuing 3 (three) Show Cause Notices as mentioned in the table below resulting in consequences faced by the Appellants and others as hereinafter described while Respondents in the respective batches of appeals were the Officers of Department who were exonerated from charges for which Revenue came in appeal against them before Tribunal :

(2.) The Appellant Sri Tejwant Singh in Appeal case No. C -997/2005 was proprietor of M/s Unicorn Industries and exporter of Microphone while he was controller of the benami export business carried out by M/s Bonita Industries in Appeal Case No. C -138/2006 and in similar nature carried out by M/s Chhabra Industries in Appeal Case No. 433/2006. Proprietor of M/s Bonita Industries was declared to be Sri Rajeevan Thouvan Kandathil and proprietor of M/s Chhabra Industries was declared to be Sri Narinder Pal Singh and the learned Adjudicating Officer recognised the proprietors as such in the three adjudications made separately as aforesaid.

(3.) THE third appellant Sri Rajiv Kumar Sharma in all the three appeals filed by him before Tribunal was an Inspector of the Department.