(1.) THE cases being connected and respondent assessee being the same, and the issues pressed before us also being the same, we dispose of both the cases by a common judgment.
(2.) IT relates to the assessment year 2003 -2004. ST.Rev. No.15 of 2013 is filed against the order passed by the Sales Tax Appellate Tribunal, Additional Branch, Kozhikode in T.A. No.15 of 2011 dated 28.9.2012. It relates to the assessment year 2004 -2005.
(3.) THE case of the assessee was that the product sold by the assessee is laminated brown paper for packing books etc. Therefore according to the assessee, since the product is a packing material, as per entry 102 to the first Schedule to the KGST Act, it is taxable at the rate of 4%.