LAWS(SC)-2009-4-240

SARDAR ESTATES Vs. ATMA RAM PROPERTIES PVT LTD

Decided On April 30, 2009
SARDAR ESTATES Appellant
V/S
ATMA RAM PROPERTIES PVT LTD Respondents

JUDGEMENT

(1.) This appeal furnishes a typical instance of a widespread malady which has infected the judicial system in the country, namely, the flagrant abuse of the process of the Court.

(2.) The respondent, which is the owner and landlord of premises No. 13/46, Scindia House, Connaught Circus, New Delhi filed an eviction petition against the appellant, who is the tenant, before the Rent Controller, Delhi in 1981. That petition was decreed on 12.5.1993 on the ground of subletting. The appellant filed an appeal before the Rent Control Tribunal which was dismissed on 22.9.1998. Thereafter he filed a second appeal which was dismissed by the Delhi High Court on 31.1.2000. Against that order he filed an SLP in this Court which was dismissed as withdrawn by order dated 8.12.2000. He then filed a Review Petition before the Delhi High Court which was dismissed on 9.2.2001. Against that order the appellant filed another SLP in this Court which was dismissed on 9.4.2001. By that order he was directed to vacate the premises and handed over physical possession to the landlord on or before 31.10.2001 subject to the usual undertaking to be filed within four weeks. However, the appellant did not file the undertaking.

(3.) In execution proceedings the appellant filed an objection on 16.3.2001 which was rejected by the Executing Court on 14.9.2001. Against the order dated 14.9.2001 the appellant filed an appeal which was dismissed as withdrawn on 1.11.2001. He filed a fresh objection on 8.11.2001 before the Executing Court which was rejected on 5.7.2002. Against that order he filed a First Appeal before the Rent Control Tribunal which was dismissed on 20.7.2002. Against the order of the Rent Control Tribunal he filed a Second Appeal before the Delhi High Court which was dismissed on 10.9.2002 by the impugned judgment. Thereafter he filed the present appeal before us.