UNION OF INDIA & ORS. Vs. DEVJEE MISHRA

JUDGEMENT

(1.) This appeal challenges the judgment of the Division Bench of the High Court of Judicature at Patna dated 23 rd June, 2009, in LPA No. 995 of 2008. By that decision the Division Bench disposed of the appeal preferred by the appellants, while affirming the order of the learned Single Judge of the same High Court in CWJC No.6289 of 2005, decided on 15 th July, 2008.

(2.) Briefly stated, the respondent at the relevant time was working in the rank of Corporal in 27th Wing of Air Force and was posted at the Air Force Bhuj Station in the State of Gujarat. Departmental action was taken against him for over staying the leave period. Charge sheet was served on him dated 18 th June 2004, which reads thus: -

(3.) Proceedings of District Court Martial against the respondent commenced on the basis of the said charge sheet. Shri A.D. Upadhyay, Wing Commander, acted as the Presiding Officer. In the said proceeding, the respondent pleaded guilty to both the charges. Even after being given opportunity to reconsider his confession, the respondent maintained his confession. This can be discerned from the proceedings and contemporaneous record. Finally, punishment of three months rigorous imprisonment to be followed by dismissal from service and also reduced in rank was recommended against him. On 25th June, 2004, the findings and sentence given by the Court was confirmed by the Competent Authority but on remitting such portion of rigorous imprisonment as would remain un -expired on the date of promulgation. On that basis the respondent stood dismissed from service. The contents of the proceedings was explained to the respondent on 2 nd July, 2004 which fact has been acknowledged by the respondent.