LAWS(SC)-2025-1-18

GOPAL KRISHAN Vs. DAULAT RAM

Decided On January 02, 2025
GOPAL KRISHAN Appellant
V/S
DAULAT RAM Respondents

JUDGEMENT

(1.) Impugned in this appeal is the judgment and order of the Punjab and Haryana High Court in RSA No. 1935 of 2015 dtd. 26/3/2018 whereby it has been held that the Will, subject matter of controversy, allegedly of one Sanjhi Ram, had not been proved, thereby finding that the Lower Appellate Court [Civil Appeal No. 27 of 2011, judgment dtd. 5/9/2014 delivered by The Court of Additional District Judge (Adhoc), Fast Track Court, Gurdaspur] had erred in holding otherwise. The said Lower Appellate Court had set aside the decree of the Civil Court [Civil Suit No. 282 of 2006, judgment dtd. 24/2/2011 delivered by Civil Judge, Senior Division, Gurdaspur] which had found that the Will and the subsequent mutation of the properties enumerated therein was bad in law, as the Will was "illegal", "null" and "void". The question that falls for our consideration is-

(2.) Facts, shorn of unnecessary details, as they appear from the record are as follows: -

(3.) The Trial Court framed seven issues primarily pertaining to, (a) validity of the Will subject matter of the present lis; (b) whether the plaintiffs are estopped by their act and conduct from filing the suit; and (c) whether the plaintiffs have the locus standi to file the suit and whether the same is maintainable, within limitation and filed with sufficient court fees, being affixed thereto.