LAWS(SC)-2024-1-23

BILKIS YAKUB RASOOL Vs. UNION OF INDIA

Decided On January 08, 2024
Bilkis Yakub Rasool Appellant
V/S
UNION OF INDIA Respondents

JUDGEMENT

(1.) Plato, the Greek Philosopher in his treatise, The Laws, underscores that punishment is to be inflicted, not for the sake of vengeance, for what is done cannot be undone, but for the sake of prevention and reformation (Thomas L. Pangle, The Laws of Plato, Basic Book Publishers, 1980). In his treatise, Plato reasons that the lawgiver, as far as he can, ought to imitate the doctor who does not apply his drug with a view to pain only, but to do the patient good. This curative theory of punishment likens penalty to medicine, administered for the good of the one who is being chastised (Trevor J. Saunders, Plato's Penal Code: Tradition, Controversy, and Reform in Greek Penology, Oxford University Press, 1991).

(2.) These writ petitions have been filed assailing the Orders dtd. 10/8/2022, granting remission and early release of respondent Nos.3 to 13 in Writ Petition (Crl.) No.491 of 2022 (which petition shall be considered to be the lead petition), who were all convicted, having been found guilty of committing heinous crimes during the large-scale riots in Gujarat on 28/2/2002 and a few days thereafter which occurred in the aftermath of the burning of the train incident in Godhra in the State of Gujarat on 27/2/2002.

(3.) The factual background in which these writ petitions have been filed is that following the aforesaid unfortunate and grave incident, a First Information Report ("FIR" for short) was registered against unknown accused, on 4/3/2002. The Investigation Agency filed a closure report stating that the accused could not be traced and the said closure report was accepted by the Judicial Magistrate vide Order dtd. 25/3/2003. The closure report was challenged by the petitioner-victim- Bilkis Yakub Rasool, before this Court in Writ Petition (Crl.) No.118 of 2003. This Court directed the reopening of the case and transferred the investigation of the same to the Central Bureau of Investigation ("CBI" for short).