NAGESHWAR SHRI KRISHNA GHOBE Vs. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA

JUDGEMENT

(1.) This is an appeal by special leave under Article 136 of the Constitution from the judgment of the Bombay High Court upholding on appeal the appellant's conviction by the Presidency Magistrate, 12th Court, Bandra, Bombay under Section 304-A, Indian Penal Code and sentence of rigorous imprisonment for 18 months and fine of Rupees 1,500/-, in default further rigorous imprisonment for four months.

(2.) According to the prosecution, on July 2, 1967, at about 4.15 p.m. the appellant was driving a B. E. S. T. motor bus bearing No. BHQ 1019 along the southern side of Tilak Road from east to west. When the bus suddenly mounted the southern footpath and dashed against an electric pole felling it down the bus stopped. A person who was near the electric pole was knocked down dead as a result of the electric pole falling on him. His right hand was severed, his head crushed with the brain matter sticking on to the wall near the electric pole. It was a double decker bus. One Harbansingh Ramsingh (called bhaiya) also substained injuries as a result of having been hit by the bus.

(3.) According to the Appellant, he was driving the bus at a moderate speed from east to west along the southern side of Tilak Road when suddenly a bhaiya, in his attempt to cross the road, came near the right wheel of the bus. He was noticed by the appellant when he was about 3 ft. away from the front right portion of the bus. In order to avoid him the appellant applied his brakes and took a turn to the left, thereby mounting the southern footpath and it was in these circumstances that he struck against the electric pole. The accident, according to his plea, occurred because of circumstances beyond his control. The Presidency Magistrate did not believe the defence version and observed: