LAWS(SC)-2022-4-3

UMADEVI NAMBIAR Vs. THAMARASSERI ROMAN CATHOLIC DIOCESE

Decided On April 01, 2022
Umadevi Nambiar Appellant
V/S
Thamarasseri Roman Catholic Diocese Respondents

JUDGEMENT

(1.) Their suit for partition having been decreed by the trial Court but reversed by the High Court in a regular first appeal, the plaintiffs have come up with the above appeal.

(2.) We have heard Shri Dushyant A. Dave, learned senior counsel for the appellant and Shri Thomas P. Joseph, learned counsel for the respondent.

(3.) The suit schedule property originally belonged to one Ullattukandiyil Sankunni. After his death, the property devolved upon his two daughters, one of whom is the appellant herein. The appellant herein executed a general Power of Attorney on 21/7/1971, registered as Document No.35 of 1971, in favour of her sister Smt. Ranee Sidhan. However, the said power was cancelled on 31/1/1985. But in the meantime, the appellant's sister was found to have executed four different documents in favour of certain third parties, assigning/releasing some properties. Therefore, the appellant first filed a suit in O.S.No.16 of 1986 followed by another suit in O.S.No.27 of 1988 against the assignees/releasees. Though a preliminary decree was passed in the second suit on 7/1/1989, the appellant came to know later that the assignees/releasees had sold the property to the respondent herein.