K S PARIAPOORNAN Vs. STATE OF KERALA

JUDGEMENT

(1.) - Retroactivity of some of the provisions of Land Acquisition Act, 1894, as amended by Land Acquisition Amendment Act, 68 of 1984, has been a source of good amount of conflict of opinion in this Court as well as among the High Courts in the country. We are not happy in adding to it but we find it inescapable, convinced as we are, that the view taken by a three-Judge Bench of this Court in Union of India v. Zora Singh, C.A. No. 4568/91 decided on 22-11-1991 (reported in 1991 (4) JT (SC) 538) requires reconsideration. We shall first state the facts , n S. L. P. No. 5514 of 1990 to indicate how the question arises.

(2.) The notification under S. 3(1) of the Kerala Land Acquisition Act (corresponding to S. 4(1) of the Land Acquisition Act 1894) was issued on 21-3-1978. Declaration under S. 6 was made on 15-5-1979. The Land Acquisition Officer (Collector) passed the award on 30-12-1980 and possession of acquired lands taken sometime in 1981. The claimants were not satisfied with the award. They asked for a reference under S. 18 which was made. The Civil Court gave its decision on 28-2-1985, enhancing the compensation.

(3.) The Land Acquisition Amendment Bill, which was later enacted into Amendment Act 68 of 84, was introduced in Parliament on 30-4-1982. The Amendment Act came into force with effect from 24-9-1984. For the present purpose it is sufficient to notice only two provisions of the Amendment Act. By Section 15 of the Amendment Act, Sub-sec. (IA) was introduced in S. 23. It reads: